LOCK HAVEN, Pa. – The 2026 Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference Football Eastern Division All-Conference Teams were announced on Wednesday, with Kutztown's Judd Novak named Offensive Athlete of the Year and Kutztown's Kyree Butler named Defensive Athlete of the Year. Shepherd's Jonathan Coleman was named Freshman of the Year, while East Stroudsburg's Jimmy Terwilliger earned Coach of the Year honors.
The All-Conference Teams and Major Awards are determined by a vote of the conference's head coaches.
Kutztown's Judd Novak was named the Eastern Division Offensive Athlete of the Year for the second straight season, adding to his 2023 Freshman of the Year award. The fifth-year quarterback completed 62.7 percent of his passes (165 of 263) for 2,361 yards and 27 touchdowns with just six interceptions, good for a 167.5 pass efficiency rating. Novak also rushed for 321 yards and four touchdowns, leading a Golden Bears offense that averaged 43.8 points per game during a 10-1 season. It marks Novak's fourth consecutive All-PSAC selection.
Another Golden Bear, Kyree Butler, was named the Eastern Division Defensive Athlete of the Year after anchoring the defensive front for KU. The senior defensive lineman recorded 24 tackles, 4.5 tackles for loss, 2.5 sacks, and three pass breakups. As a team, Kutztown allowed just 15.5 points and 69.7 rushing yards per game, holding opponents to 2.5 yards per carry. Butler was also 2025 All-PSAC East First Team selection.
Shepherd's Jonathan Coleman was named the Eastern Division Freshman of the Year and earned All-PSAC East First Team honors at defensive back in his first collegiate season. Coleman finished with three interceptions, two forced fumbles (tied for the team lead) and a fumble recovery, along with 31 tackles, 2.5 tackles for loss and a pass breakup, helping the Rams to an 8-3 record.
East Stroudsburg head coach Jimmy Terwilliger was named the Eastern Division Coach of the Year for the first time. He becomes just the third individual to win both a PSAC Coach of the Year and a PSAC Athlete of the Year award, which he earned during his playing days. Picked second in the 2026 preseason coaches' poll, the Warriors went 6-0 in PSAC East play to win their first division title since sharing it in 2003, ending Kutztown's run of three straight East crowns. ESU clinched a spot in the PSAC Championship Game with a 32-25 overtime win over No. 3 Kutztown on Oct. 31, finished 9-2 overall and placed 13 players on the All-PSAC East teams, including nine First Team selections.
Of the 56 total PSAC Football Eastern Division All-Conference honorees this fall, 21 are former all-conference selections, while 35 have been named to an All-PSAC team for the first time in their respective careers.
Find the complete list of 2026 PSAC Football Eastern Division All-Conference Teams and Major Award winners below.
Eastern Division Offensive Athlete of the Year: Judd Novak, Kutztown
Eastern Division Defensive Athlete of the Year: Kyree Butler, Kutztown
Eastern Division Freshman of the Year: Jonathan Coleman, Shepherd
Eastern Division Coach of the Year: Jimmy Terwilliger, East Stroudsburg
PSAC FOOTBALL EASTERN DIVISION ALL-CONFERENCE OFFENSIVE FIRST TEAM
| Position |
Name |
Cl. |
Institution |
| QB |
Judd Novak^^* |
5th |
Kutztown |
| RB |
Declan Clancy^ |
So. |
Bloomsburg |
| RB |
Matt Frame* |
5th |
East Stroudsburg |
| RB |
Jaedyn Stewart^^ |
5th |
Kutztown |
| OT |
Ishmael Dobson |
Jr. |
Kutztown |
| OT |
Fynn McDonald |
Jr. |
East Stroudsburg |
| OG |
Adam Conklin^ |
5th |
Kutztown |
| OG |
Pat Reynolds^ |
5th |
East Stroudsburg |
| C |
CJ Conti^ |
5th |
Kutztown |
| TE |
Luke Maxwell^ |
Sr. |
Kutztown |
| WR |
Chris Adegunle |
R-So. |
Shippensburg |
| WR |
Elijah Ford |
5th |
East Stroudsburg |
| WR |
Noah Kracyla^ |
Sr. |
Kutztown |
| RS |
D'Myo Hunter |
R-Fr. |
Shepherd |
| PK |
Ty Quintois** |
Sr. |
East Stroudsburg |
PSAC FOOTBALL EASTERN DIVISION ALL-CONFERENCE DEFENSIVE FIRST TEAM
| Position |
Name |
Cl. |
Institution |
| DL |
Ashton Blose* |
Sr. |
East Stroudsburg |
| DL |
Kyree Butler* |
Sr. |
Kutztown |
| DL |
Ian Donohue |
R-Jr. |
Bloomsburg |
| DL |
Mikey Gray* |
Sr. |
Kutztown |
| DL |
Freddie Retter** |
Gr. |
Kutztown |
| LB |
Bryce Beutler^ |
Sr. |
Millersville |
| LB |
Nahzier Booker |
Jr. |
Bloomsburg |
| LB |
Eden Johnson*^ |
5th |
Kutztown |
| LB |
Nate Myers* |
R-Jr. |
Shippensburg |
| DB |
Jonathan Coleman |
Fr. |
Shepherd |
| DB |
Everette Dingle** |
5th |
East Stroudsburg |
| DB |
Harold Hill IV |
Jr. |
East Stroudsburg |
| DB |
D'Myo Hunter |
R-Fr. |
Shepherd |
| P |
Adam Noll^^ |
Sr. |
East Stroudsburg |
PSAC FOOTBALL EASTERN DIVISION ALL-CONFERENCE OFFENSIVE SECOND TEAM
| Position |
Name |
Cl. |
Institution |
| QB |
Michael Hardyway |
Gr. |
Shepherd |
| RB |
Mekhi Ashby |
Jr. |
Millersville |
| RB |
Ian Mauldin |
R-Fr. |
Shepherd |
| RB |
Ajani Walker |
Sr. |
East Stroudsburg |
| OT |
Ross Bobbin |
Sr. |
Bloomsburg |
| OT |
Cole Kozlowski |
R-Jr. |
West Chester |
| OG |
Jake Bobbin |
Sr. |
Bloomsburg |
| OG |
Caleb Herb |
R-Jr. |
Shepherd |
| C |
Josh Crummitt* |
Sr. |
Shepherd |
| TE |
Reese Clark |
R-Jr. |
West Chester |
| WR |
Dylan McKenzie |
R-Jr. |
West Chester |
| WR |
Carrington Nickens-Yzer |
Sr. |
Shepherd |
| WR |
Lenniek Preston |
Sr. |
Kutztown |
| RS |
Lenniek Preston |
Sr. |
Kutztown |
| PK |
Peter Kashynski |
So. |
Bloomsburg |
PSAC FOOTBALL EASTERN DIVISION ALL-CONFERENCE DEFENSIVE SECOND TEAM
| Position |
Name |
Cl. |
Institution |
| DL |
Luke Hines |
R-Jr. |
Shippensburg |
| DL |
Max Hostetter |
5th |
Millersville |
| DL |
Justin McGill |
Fr. |
Shepherd |
| DL |
Tee Peete |
Sr. |
Kutztown |
| DL |
Jake Williamson^^ |
5th |
East Stroudsburg |
| LB |
Malachi Barnes |
R-So. |
Shepherd |
| LB |
Camerin Gross |
Jr. |
East Stroudsburg |
| LB |
Cam Jefferson |
Jr. |
East Stroudsburg |
| LB |
LJ Smith |
So. |
Kutztown |
| DB |
Mike Fayemi |
5th |
Kutztown |
| DB |
Elijah Motley |
R-Fr. |
West Chester |
| DB |
Zach Perta |
Sr. |
Kutztown |
| DB |
Reggie Snowden |
Jr. |
Shepherd |
| P |
Wilson Ingerski |
Jr. |
Shippensburg |
* Indicates previous All-PSAC First Team selection
^ Indicates previous All-PSAC Second Team selection