| Year |
Female |
Male |
| 2024-25 |
Anna Igims, Slippery Rock (XC, Track & Field) |
Brayden Long, Slippery Rock (Football) |
| 2023-24 |
Samantha Pirosko, Gannon (Women's Basketball) |
Brayden Long, Slippery Rock (Football) |
| 2022-23 |
Divonne Franklin, California (Track & Field) |
John Paul Kromka, Pitt-Johnstown (Men's Basketball) |
| 2021-22 |
Hannah Marsteller, Shippensburg (Softball) |
Connor Hamilton, Slippery Rock (Baseball) |
| 2020-21 |
Paige Mikesell, IUP (Women's Swimming) |
Samuel Hartman, Seton Hill (Men's Track & Field) |
| 2019-20 |
Becca Cubbler, Bloomsburg (Women's Swimming) |
Joseph Westrick, Gannon (Men's Cross Country) |
| 2018-19 |
Alicia Belko, Cal U (Cross Country) |
Jared Melone, West Chester (Baseball) |
| 2017-18 |
Natalie Cignetti, IUP (Volleyball) |
Marcus Martin, Slippery Rock (Football) |
| 2016-17 |
Sabrina Anderson, Slippery Rock (Tr & F) |
David Reinhardt, Slippery Rock (Tr & F) |
| 2015-16 |
Sabrina Anderson, Slippery Rock (Tr & F) |
Colin McKee, Mercyhurst (Baseball) |
| 2014-15 |
Kristin Day, Clarion (Diving) |
Aaron Dinzeo, California (XC) |
| 2013-14 |
Tabitha Bemis, Edinboro (Tr & F) |
Dan Altavilla, Mercyhurst (Baseball) |
| 2012-13 |
Hannah Heeter, Clarion (Volleyball, Basketball) |
Matt Tholis, East Stroudsburg (Tr & F) |
| 2011-12 |
Neely Spence, Shippensburg (XC) |
Joe Wendle, West Chester (Baseball) |
| 2010-11 |
Neely Spence, Shippensburg (Tr & F, XC) |
Ian Wild, Mercyhurst (Football) |
| 2009-10 |
Mary Dell, Shippensburg (Tr & F, XC) |
Jarrod King, Edinboro (Wrestling) |
| 2008-09 |
Jen Blasko, Slippery Rock (Volleyball) |
Kyle Goldcamp, Gannon (Basketball) |
| 2007-08 |
Jennifer Hansen, Slippery Rock (Tr & F) |
Chris Cummings, Mansfield (Tr & F, XC) |
| 2006-07 |
Jamie Wolf, Clarion (Diving) |
Chris Robson, Lock Haven (XC) |
| 2005-06 |
Heather Chantiles, Shippensburg (Softball) |
Lloyd Price, California (Football) |
| 2004-05 |
Laura Kline, Kutztown (Field Hockey, Tr & F) |
Mike Larson, California (Baseball) |
| 2003-04 |
Karen McCready, Slippery Rock (Tr & F) |
Mike Larson, California (Baseball) |
| 2002-03 |
Laura Hall, IUP (Volleyball) |
Shawn Colten, Clarion (Swimming) |
| 2001-02 |
Laura Hall, IUP (Volleyball) |
Alex Daecher, Kutztown (Football) |
| 2000-01 |
Kim Rochon, West Chester (Lacrosse) |
Matt Edwards, Mansfield (Baseball) |
| 1999-00 |
Nikki DiLoreto, Clarion (Swimming) |
Tim Kusniez, Slippery Rock (Football) |
| 1998-99 |
Molly Carr, IUP (Basketball, Softball) |
Jason Hilt, Kutztown (Tr & F) |
| 1997-98 |
Molly Carr, IUP (Basketball, Softball) |
Dave Sabolcik, Slippery Rock (Football) |
| 1996-97 |
Kerry Novak, California (Softball) |
Steve Witte, Clarion (Football) |
| 1995-96 |
Lori Robinson, Slippery Rock (Basketball) |
Mike Resetar, Mansfield (Baseball) |
| 1994-95 |
Shelly Miller, Bloomsburg (FH, Softball) |
Mark Metzka, Slippery Rock (Basketball) |
| 1993-94 |
Cindy Kepler, Shippensburg (Swimming) |
Steve Economopoulos, Ship (Soc, Base) |
| 1992-93 |
Theresa Kovach, Lock Haven (Softball) |
Ray Guiterrez, California (Basketball) |
| 1991-92 |
Kara Hopkins, Edinboro (Volleyball, Swim) |
Dave Burmeister, Clarion (Football) |
| 1990-91 |
Kara Hopkins, Edinboro (Volleyball, Swim) |
Tom Kuntzleman, Bloomburg (Wrestling) |