The PSAC Sportsmanship Award was initiated in the 2008-09 academic year and is given annually to one male and one female student-athlete that best exemplifies the spirit of sportsmanship and who has demonstrated the values of respect and integrity through a specific action ideally directed toward an opponent. Nominees must also have represented his/her institution in a positive way during competition and must have demonstrated good citizenship outside of competition by fostering a good public image. The PSAC Sportsmanship Award was implemented by the PSAC Student-Athlete Advisory Committee (SAAC). Nominees are submitted by PSAC institutions and voted on by the SAAC.

Year	Female	Male
2021-22	Grace Beierschmitt, Women's Swimming - Blooomsburg	Andrew Dunn Jr., Wrestling - Kutztown
2020-21	No awards due to COVID-19
2019-20	No awards due to COVID-19
2018-19	Cadie Kiser, Lock Haven & Kutztown women's basketball	Derrick Ellis Jr., Mercyhurst
2016-17	Lock Haven men's and women's cross country	Lock Haven men's and women's cross country
2015-16	Seton Hill women's soccer	Ryan Paisley, Bloomsburg
2014-15		Bobby Shorthouse, Lock Haven
2013-14	Carla Maestre, California	Tyler Matunis, Kutztown
2012-13	Millersville women's lacrosse	LeQuan Chapman, West Chester
2011-12	Edinboro's men and women's swimming	Stephen Grib, Bloomsburg
2010-11	Kristen Montello, West Chester	Eric Berringer, California
2009-10	Neely Spence, Shippensburg	Kyle King, Mercyhurst
2008-09	Jamie Maloney, Clarion	Chris Clark, California